Medium 176

Expert Recommendations

"This tiny, retro shop in West Town serves the city's, if not the country's, best pie. The aroma of old-fashioned butter crust wafts onto the sidewalk, making it nearly impossible to resist. Whether you're in the mood for savory (beef and Guinness stout) or sweet (ginger custard, sugar cream), baker Paula Haney has got you covered. Drop by Friday for a pie flight."

Also at Hoosier Mama Pie Co.

Featured Content

Best Pies in the U.S.
March 12, 2015

Fruit-filled, crustless, savory, and a la mode, pie is one of the best food forms out there.

The Best Desserts
January 22, 2015

Because there's nothing like finishing off a meal the right way! Get your sweet treats here.